Are Gunite Pools Better Than Fiberglass Pools?
Choosing the right material for your new pool influences everything from long-term maintenance to aesthetic appeal. Gunite and fiberglass are among the most popular pool construction options today. Each type offers distinct benefits and drawbacks.
At Nolascapes Pool & Outdoors LLC, the best choice depends on various factors, including design preferences, soil conditions, budget, and how you plan to use the pool.
Let's look at the differences between these two types of swimming pools:
1. Durability and Structural Integrity
Gunite pools use a rebar framework sprayed with a concrete and sand mixture. Once cured, this creates an extremely strong and rigid structure. This structural strength is one of the primary reasons why gunite is favored for large, deep, or complexly shaped pools. If properly maintained, these pools can last for decades.Fiberglass pools, on the other hand, are pre-manufactured shells made from molded fiberglass-reinforced plastic. While they are also quite durable, they are more susceptible to certain conditions, such as shifting soil.
2. Installation Timeline and Convenience
One significant advantage of fiberglass pools is the significantly shorter installation time. Because the shell is prefabricated and delivered in one piece, installation can take as little as one to two weeks, depending on site conditions. In contrast, gunite pools require extensive excavation, framing, spraying, and curing time. The entire process may take six to eight weeks or longer. Weather delays and curing time contribute to this extended timeline.3. Customization Options
Gunite pools offer virtually unlimited customization. Everything can be tailored to suit personal preferences, from shape and size to depth, tanning ledges, built-in spas, and steps. Fiberglass pools, while available in a wide variety of pre-designed shapes and sizes, offer less flexibility in terms of customization. What you gain in speed and convenience, you trade-off in design freedom. Add-ons such as tanning ledges or built-in spas may still be available but within the limits of the existing mold.4. Surface Finish and Comfort
The interior finish of a pool significantly affects both comfort and maintenance. Fiberglass pools have a smooth, nonporous gel coat surface, which feels pleasant underfoot and reduces the likelihood of algae growth. Gunite pools are typically finished with plaster, pebble, or tile surfaces, which may feel rougher. While these finishes offer a wider aesthetic range, they may require more frequent maintenance and resurfacing over time to maintain their appearance and prevent deterioration.5. Maintenance Requirements
Another area where fiberglass pools generally have an edge when it comes to maintenance. The nonporous surface inhibits algae and bacterial growth, making water chemistry easier to maintain. They also typically require fewer chemicals, lower electricity use (due to fewer cleaning needs), and less frequent vacuuming. By comparison, granite pools are porous and more prone to algae buildup, especially in corners and textured surfaces. Regular brushing, chemical balancing, and occasional resurfacing are part of the long-term maintenance routine. These ongoing needs can lead to higher operational costs over time.6. Cost Considerations
Initial costs vary depending on the complexity of the design and site preparation. Generally, fiberglass pools have a lower upfront cost, especially when considering installation time and labor. However, the price can increase with add-ons like water features, decking, or automation systems. Gunite pools tend to have a higher initial cost due to labor-intensive construction, but their long-term durability and high-end appeal can add more value to the property. Ongoing maintenance costs for gunite pools may also be higher.7. Aesthetics and Property Value
Both pool types can enhance the look of a backyard and boost home value, but gunite pools offer a higher level of architectural integration and landscaping synergy. The ability to fully customize the shape, depth, and finish allows gunite pools to blend seamlessly with elaborate outdoor environments.Fiberglass pools offer sleek, clean lines and modern finishes, which are appealing in contemporary settings. However, the pre-set forms might not entirely match unique property layouts or complex terrain.
For high-grade gunite pools, call Nolascapes Pool & Outdoors LLC at 504-330-8479. You can also use this Online Form to contact us, and one of our team members will call you back.
Areas We Service in Louisiana